I find our attitude to David Hare very odd. He writes good plays. He has a loyal public. He addresses contemporary issues. Yet, increasingly, his work seems to attract the wrath of the “commentariat” – not so much the critics as that vast body of men and women who have space to fill in weekly columns. It occurred with his excellent play about Iraq, Stuff Happens. It’s happened again with Gethsemane, his fascinating new play at the National Theatre which refers obliquely to recent scandals but which is really about New Labour’s lack of Utopian vision.
The play itself got mixed overnight reviews, which is fair enough, but what fascinated me was the rash of columnitis that followed. Ian Jack in the Guardian told us that it wasn’t “a play for today”. David Lister took the same tack in the Independent, informing us that plays like Hare’s “can all too rapidly become rather last season”. And Dominic Cavendish, who is at least a critic, went further in the Daily Telegraph, suggesting that Gethsemane was proof of theatre’s recent ineffectualness as “a podium for oppositional thought”. To all of which my main reaction is a polite raspberry.
For a start, most people got Hare’s play wrong. Although it makes glancing reference to private problems afflicting Labour ministers, it is really about something far more serious – the reduction of government to a form of managerial pragmatism rather than an instrument of change. It’s also about the difficulty of governing well when the press behaves like a pack of scalp hunters. Even the admirers, myself included, missed a key point: it is an optimistic play arguing that, just as Christ overcame his night of doubt at Gethsemane, so those on the Left need to keep the faith in dark times.
To argue that Gethsemane is already dated because it deals with the Blair years strikes me as plain dotty. It’s rather like saying Granville Barker’s Waste is irrelevant because Herbert Asquith is dead, or that Ghosts is past its sell-by date because syphilis is now curable. I’m not saying Hare’s play is as good as either of those. But it tackles a living issue – the creeping corrosion of our political culture. It will also, I suspect, gain stature with time. Hare’s The Absence of War was pooh-poohed on its first appearance in 1993. It now looks like a highly prophetic play in which Labour, after four election defeats, decides that the only way back to power is to become more like the Tories.
What really intrigues me, however, is why Hare attracts such animus. It can’t just be the plays themselves, which unless I’m missing something, have the capacity of a John le Carre or Graham Greene novel to combine a suspense-filled plot with a political or philosophical idea. Is it perhaps something in Hare’s combative nature and unwillingness to suffer fools gladly that offends our scribes and pharisees? One hopes not.
My own suspicion is that Hare irritates columnar opinion-makers because he dares to trespass on their own ground. He writes about cultural relativism (Amy’s View), the disastrous effects of railway privatisation (The Permanent Way), the origins of the Iraq War (Stuff Happens) and now, in Gethsemane, the decay of political vision. These weighty matters are regarded as the province of the pundits rather than a mere dramatist. But, in airing them on public stages, Hare has done more than anyone in my lifetime to bring the British theatre into contact with society. Far from being “Hare today, gone tomorrow”, the best of his work will, I suspect, endure.
I spent two years reporting the Blair government and I found large parts of the story of Gethsemane implausible and off-target. Very little of it rang true or offered me anything in the way of a fresh insight into New Labour, and I suspect that most of the political commentators who saw the play felt the same. The subplot about the journalist and the minister’s daughter was just too absurd. I can put up with implausible plotting very easily in the theatre if the play really crackles dramatically, and this one just didn’t get off the ground, despite good dialogue, acting and characters. When DH sticks close to the facts as in The Permanent Way, he’s excellent. When he makes it up, as in Gethsemane, it’s a damp squib. Stuff Happens falls somewhere between the two. Funnily enough, I went to the BFI on Tuesday to see the film of DH’s early play Knuckle, and that had many of the same plot faults as Gethsemane. It’s supposed to be about the City of London but DH doesn’t know enough about the City to write it, so the plot revolves around a dodgy property deal in Guildford.
Pingback: brachiferous agrege campholic
Pingback: bishopling
Pingback: rotator cuff full recovery
Pingback: Sophie
Pingback: rifles
Pingback: Leebo9
Pingback: dui Orlando lawyers
Pingback: dui attorneys Fort Myers
Pingback: dui Clearwater lawyers
Pingback: Fort Myers criminal defense attorney
Pingback: Learn Piano
Pingback: cafelearn72
Pingback: dui lawyers Los Angeles
Pingback: homepage erstellen
Pingback: vehicle warranty companies in texas
Pingback: ceramic watches
Pingback: online solicitation of a minor
Pingback: arrasshops
Pingback: Bakersfield DUI Lawyer
Pingback: cliquez ici
Pingback: California DUI Attorney
Pingback: hachoir a viande electrique
Pingback: iPhone 5 release date
Pingback: psd to html5
Pingback: Tyler
Pingback: bodybuilding pics
Pingback: Android Antivirus
Pingback: Best Weight Loss Plans
Pingback: Michael DuBasso
Pingback: plumbers raleigh
Pingback: nursing schools in new york
Pingback: shogun 2 trainer
Pingback: how to unlock iphone 51
Pingback: best whey protein brand for building muscle
Pingback: carpet cleaning
Pingback: natural skin care
Pingback: tires for sale
Pingback: software to jailbreak 4 iphones
Pingback: iphone jailbreak help
Pingback: Apartamenty Zakopane
Pingback: unlock iphone 4
Pingback: banners
Pingback: Masterminds TV Show
Pingback: Scrapebox
Pingback: woman
Pingback: Bodybuilding Diet Plan For Men
Pingback: video production maryland
Pingback: jual susu
Pingback: prettygirl
Pingback: http://www.tablettegraphique.org/
Pingback: casque audio sans fil pour tv
Pingback: best criminal lawyers in Fort Myers fl
Pingback: SEO Marketing Services
Pingback: how to make your boobs bigger without surgery
Pingback: trampoline avec filet pas cher
Pingback: turbine à glace professionnelle
Pingback: gloria jeans coffee franchise fee
Pingback: Dedicated Server Hosting
Pingback: Massage Therapy
Pingback: climatiseur mobile silencieux
Pingback: plancha electrique tefal
Pingback: montre gps
Pingback: http://www.parcbebe.net/
Pingback: veloenfant
Pingback: glaciere electrique
Pingback: Hasbeans
Pingback: WWW
Pingback: Forex trading
Pingback: Locksmith In Toronto
Pingback: the diet solution program
Pingback: Social bookmarking site
Pingback: pnc.com
Pingback: Looking for a Job in Brownville, NE
Pingback: Miguelina Prewer
Pingback: casque sans fil xbox 360
Pingback: épilateur électrique
Pingback: echelle telescopique pas cher
Pingback: kwiaty
Pingback: Land Rover Parts Canada
Pingback: machine a biere
Pingback: Pufa
Pingback: Herbal Smoke Reviews
Pingback: legal cannabis
Pingback: buy marijuana
Pingback: obrazy olejne
Pingback: Baby Changing Table Dresser
Pingback: bahamas charter flights
Pingback: asian women for marriage
Pingback: fabulous stuff
Pingback: Kwiaty Ozdobne
Pingback: Wheel Repair
Pingback: Archiwizacja Danych
Pingback: archiwizacja online
Pingback: sztachety plastikowe
Pingback: ghost recon future soldier
Pingback: inventia
Pingback: credit building credit cards
Pingback: Rental Mobil Jogja
Pingback: this site
Pingback: how to get rid of acne spots
Pingback: http://www.maldivesvids.com/tag/maldives-hotel/
Pingback: citi image
Pingback: chase online logon
Pingback: Click!
Pingback: free stock photos
Pingback: london free ads
Pingback: I like your style
Pingback: Hoodia
Pingback: manchester freeads
Pingback: Dubai 2012
Pingback: http://s1066.photobucket.com/home/antiagingskincare05/index
Pingback: skin care
Pingback: backup online
Pingback: Leading Brands Publishing
Pingback: graduation bbq
Pingback: what a good read
Pingback: kids shoes
Pingback: tv links
Pingback: jacket
Pingback: touch mobile website
Pingback: Strona o ekonomi
Pingback: Stage Golf Marrakech Maroc
Pingback: ahh bra
Pingback: Car Rental Costa Rica
Pingback: micro sites
Pingback: como enamorar una mujer
Pingback: Free RPG Games
Pingback: Wholesale hCG Labs
Pingback: Comment Ca Marche
Pingback: drunk driving lawyers Jacksonville
Pingback: www.spellcheckonline.com
Pingback: Conseil Agadir Maroc
Pingback: hale namiotowe
Pingback: San Diego dui attorneys
Pingback: sztachety
Pingback: kwiaty
Pingback: accounting
Pingback: Homepage
Pingback: http://carobking.com
Pingback: fifa 12 coin generator
Pingback: zavodenje nad zavodenjima
Pingback: http://www.bzgames.de/
Pingback: Fashion Trends
Pingback: hotels in niagara falls
Pingback: Click Here
Pingback: pozycjonowanie stron www
Pingback: Links
Pingback: How to win the lottery
Pingback: triactol reviews
Pingback: How to win the lottery
Pingback: levitra
Pingback: Koolatron Mini Fridge
Pingback: cialis
Pingback: PoliticalRuck.us
Pingback: Golf Agadir Maroc
Pingback: Car Service Houston
Pingback: Check this out!
Pingback: Regały magazynowe
Pingback: Cell Phones Spartphones GSM PDA
Pingback: i want to be a slut
Pingback: organizzazione golf
Pingback: ogrodzenia dla koni
Pingback: backup
Pingback: ogrodzenia dla koni
Pingback: ps3console.com
Pingback: obrazy dla firm
Pingback: vitiligo treatment
Pingback: internet
Pingback: sjukvårdsprodukter
Pingback: united kingdom
Pingback: escort employment
Pingback: BUCKSLOCALECONOMICPARTNERSHIP
Pingback: amazing discounts
Pingback: PoliticalRuck.us
Pingback: fashion jewelry
Pingback: raspberry ketones
Pingback: aaron wall
Pingback: Click!
Pingback: robe pas cher
Pingback: viagra
Pingback: Vancouver personal training
Pingback: rechtsschutzversicherung vergleich stiftung warentest
Pingback: http://www.funandsafedriving.com/mapquest-driving-directions.html
Pingback: swiss rolex submariner replica
Pingback: home remedies for acne scars
Pingback: hausratversicherung
Pingback: Vergleich Hausratversicherung
Pingback: seo massachusetts
Pingback: king commissions
Pingback: attractions in Hanoi
Pingback: jcpenney coupon code
Pingback: http://www.friteusesanshuile.net/
Pingback: sony camescope hd
Pingback: http://www.minilavevaisselle.fr/
Pingback: disque dur interne
Pingback: archiwizacja danych
Pingback: naprawa ploterów HP
Pingback: węgiel Poznań