Comments on: Week 3: Results http://blogs.whatsonstage.com/2008/04/13/week-3-results/ Sun, 20 Jul 2008 13:42:01 +0000 http://wordpress.org/?v=2.2.2 By: Lara http://blogs.whatsonstage.com/2008/04/13/week-3-results/#comment-7641 Lara Wed, 16 Apr 2008 21:06:58 +0000 http://blogs.whatsonstage.com/2008/04/13/week-3-results/#comment-7641 Jodie, Jessie, Sarah & Rachel are the strongest & most likeliest contenders for the role of Nancy & this year the competition is that much closer that it is going to be harder to choose one in particular. They are all very talented and will no doubt succeed in other projects, as have all the previous Josephs and Marias. Good luck to them & I'm really enjoying IDA. Jodie, Jessie, Sarah & Rachel are the strongest & most likeliest contenders for the role of Nancy & this year the competition is that much closer that it is going to be harder to choose one in particular. They are all very talented and will no doubt succeed in other projects, as have all the previous Josephs and Marias.
Good luck to them & I’m really enjoying IDA.

]]> By: Lily http://blogs.whatsonstage.com/2008/04/13/week-3-results/#comment-7590 Lily Tue, 15 Apr 2008 20:03:09 +0000 http://blogs.whatsonstage.com/2008/04/13/week-3-results/#comment-7590 The right two were in the sing off this week. I thought Keisha sang her solo song better then Tara did but Tara was better in the sing off and showed a bit more emotion. Jodie and Jessie are real contenders. The right two were in the sing off this week. I thought Keisha sang her solo song better then Tara did but Tara was better in the sing off and showed a bit more emotion.
Jodie and Jessie are real contenders.

]]> By: Peter http://blogs.whatsonstage.com/2008/04/13/week-3-results/#comment-7587 Peter Tue, 15 Apr 2008 18:03:08 +0000 http://blogs.whatsonstage.com/2008/04/13/week-3-results/#comment-7587 I totally disagree with Melissa about Keisha. She probably has the best voice quality in the competition. The song choices have done nothing to show her as a potential Nancy. You obviously have no knowledge of singing/voice training if you think Keisha sings out of tune. Francesca,Niamh and particularly Tara were dreadfully out of tune at times on Saturday. Keisha may not appeal to you but do not accuse her of singing out of tune when most of the other contestants have had tuning problems during the first three weeks. I do, however, agree that Jessie and Jodie along with Sarah and Keisha would be acceptable winners I agree with Maia that Tara should never have made the final twelve but this also applies to Amy, Ashley and Niamh. I totally disagree with Melissa about Keisha. She probably has the best voice quality in the competition. The song choices have done nothing to show her as a potential Nancy. You obviously have no knowledge of singing/voice training if you think Keisha sings out of tune. Francesca,Niamh and particularly Tara were dreadfully out of tune at times on Saturday. Keisha may not appeal to you but do not accuse her of singing out of tune when most of the other contestants have had tuning problems during the first three weeks.

I do, however, agree that Jessie and Jodie along with Sarah and Keisha would be acceptable winners

I agree with Maia that Tara should never have made the final twelve but this also applies to Amy, Ashley and Niamh.

]]> By: Melissa http://blogs.whatsonstage.com/2008/04/13/week-3-results/#comment-7584 Melissa Tue, 15 Apr 2008 16:11:49 +0000 http://blogs.whatsonstage.com/2008/04/13/week-3-results/#comment-7584 I disagree. For two weeks now Keisha has been in the bottom two, and for two weeks now she has sang out of tune and lacking emotion in the sing off. Both Cleo and Tara excelled in their performances and were far superior to Keisha's dull uninteresting passionless performance. Is this history repeating itself as I seem to remember similar judegment at the same stage in Any Dream Will Do. Just as Daniel who sang Bring Him Home with far more passion than Lewis got voted off to early, I think this was the case here. However, regardless of how talented any of these girls are and they ARE all talented, as with Maria and Joseph I think there are two people who stand out for the role of Nancy. The other girls will be successful in the theatre/music industry but for me Nancy should go to Jessie or Jodie. I disagree. For two weeks now Keisha has been in the bottom two, and for two weeks now she has sang out of tune and lacking emotion in the sing off. Both Cleo and Tara excelled in their performances and were far superior to Keisha’s dull uninteresting passionless performance. Is this history repeating itself as I seem to remember similar judegment at the same stage in Any Dream Will Do. Just as Daniel who sang Bring Him Home with far more passion than Lewis got voted off to early, I think this was the case here. However, regardless of how talented any of these girls are and they ARE all talented, as with Maria and Joseph I think there are two people who stand out for the role of Nancy. The other girls will be successful in the theatre/music industry but for me Nancy should go to Jessie or Jodie.

]]> By: Maia http://blogs.whatsonstage.com/2008/04/13/week-3-results/#comment-7535 Maia Sun, 13 Apr 2008 21:27:07 +0000 http://blogs.whatsonstage.com/2008/04/13/week-3-results/#comment-7535 I am so glad Tara went. She had to. How she ever got through the first auditions is beyond me. And how she survived this far!! I think Rachel or Sarah should go all the way. Rachel in particular has such a wonderful presence. I am so glad Tara went. She had to. How she ever got through the first auditions is beyond me. And how she survived this far!!
I think Rachel or Sarah should go all the way. Rachel in particular has such a wonderful presence.

]]>